Should the Spin Serve be Illegal in 2023

Spin serves, which involve imparting spin on the ball by striking it with a tilted racquet face, are allowed in pickleball, but there are a few arguments that could be made for why they should not be allowed:

1. Spin serves can be difficult to return: Spin serves can be challenging for opponents to read and return, especially for beginners or players who are not used to dealing with spin. This can lead to unbalanced and potentially unfair matches, as players who are skilled at hitting spin serves may have an advantage over their opponents.

2. Spin serves can slow down the game: Spin serves often result in lower-paced rallies, as players may have a harder time hitting aggressively when the ball has spin on it. This can lead to slower-paced games and may not be as enjoyable for some players.

3. Spin serves can be harder to execute: Spin serves require a high level of skill and precision to execute effectively. This can make them difficult for some players to master, which may result in a less inclusive and enjoyable game for all players.

4. Spin serves may not align with the spirit of pickleball: Pickleball is often described as a recreational and social sport that is designed to be fun and easy to learn. Allowing spin serves may go against the spirit of the game and may not be in line with the goals of many pickleball players.

Overall, while spin serves can be a useful tactic for advanced players, there are valid arguments for why they should not be allowed in pickleball. Some players may feel that they detract from the enjoyment of the game and are not in line with the spirit of pickleball as a recreational and social sport.